Università Telematica “e-Campus”
Facoltà di Giurisprudenza
Corso di Laurea in Scienze della Comunicazione
Curriculum Digital Marketing
From game to sport. The enhancement of skills in the poker live cultural change.
Supervisor: Prof. Bonomi Sabrina
Degree Dissertation of:
Academic Year 2020/2021
In our country, the subject of the regulation of the poker discipline has been a subject of debate since the dawn of its practice, keeping the matter of skill at the heart of the debate. The diatribe between game of luck and game of skill has never encountered unanimous opinions (or at the very least dominant opinions) within the community. At the preliminary question, therefore, what is meant by skills in poker, can be defined by the comprehension level of quality, by the development and implementation of basic strategies and principles acquired by the single individual through empirical literature and/or experience. There is no evidence contesting that in the traditional game dynamics of the poker tournament it matters how profoundly one can know their own winning chances or how evolved the strategies are that one possesses to define one’s advantages against the opponents, taken into account in every section of the spot (played hand). This type of scientific knowledge is often considered useful to acquire greater awareness on the risks of ruin and to foster the development of new strategies in order to face the opponents in the long term. However, there is no evidence considering it sufficient to guarantee – structurally – that the winner of a spot or of a tournament can be the player that demonstrated using a greater amount of skills.
The scenario can be expanded if one considers that the same game dynamics produced a further negative effect in the popular culture in a way that, even if a player of notoriously known skills and recognized by the community as such, were to win a tournament (online or live), here too, – for this writer – after approximately a fifteen-year period of qualitative analytical observations carried out directly on-site (first from the prospective of a professional player and then from the prospective of authorized personnel), would be in any case considered as “particularly fortunate”. This is the reason why it is believed that in the poker environment, played live or online, to win the tournaments it is necessary to start at the back and win the shot until the end of the spot, at least twice throughout the entire session without, obviously, losing with the shots in which more often you would start with an advantage. With regard to the feasibility of the cultural change that this Degree Dissertation aims to understand, one can consider this period as the acceptance period.
In the poker live environment, as in the online, between the players there is a strong mono-prospective tendency to consider skilled a player with remarkable mathematical abilities in relation to the application and exploitation skills of the supplied softwares, utilised for the programmed quantitative analysis.
In actual fact, playing live tournaments is not the exact same thing as playing online tournaments. To be able to compete in the professional online poker field, it is extremely necessary that every player possesses great willpower, predisposition to studying and always acquiring new knowledge, logical-mathematical capacities and a wide knowledge of software data management and solver specific for the poker world.
The aim of this work is to understand whether and how to introduce new rules in the poker Texas Hold’em, for the purpose of a possible recognition as a skill sports discipline and how to find a formula that were to lift it from the gambling category, in which still remains considered.
The theme, for the writer, has been of great interest since 2008 managing firstly to unfold solely one part of the problem, whilst the scientific element that could have completed the process was still unaccounted for, i.e. intervening on the nature of the rough game structure and eliminating the aleatory component, primeval leverage emerged from the old social-economic paradigm which characterised the culture and society of its origins.
In this work it was considered possible trying to fill the gap and find a solution to the enigma.
The first chapter is the occasion to understand the analysis that the researcher conducted in identifying the adopted solutions. Building on the judicial, academic and dictionary definitions of “Sport” and on the characteristics that a discipline must present to be considered a skill sports activity, critical issues were identified. Criticalities that limit the poker Texas Hold’em in not being recognised the skill component which every athlete must demonstrate to own in order to excel on the opponents. The analysis process carried on in identifying the principal factors that influence the skills in poker, that is the Information acquired and the stack Magnitude. With the application of piecewise semantics the poker fundamental Theorem of Sklansky is revisited from a new perspective, stating the logic of the poker information completeness which is the basis of the Skill Index-Ia calculation for every phase of the spot; this would allow the discipline to be considered amongst the categories of skill sports activities, that is, the skills management in defining the result of the athletic performance. Identified in the all-in process, the principal criticality binding the discipline to the gabling category – produced in any phase antecedent the river phase – the skill index will establish a partial distribution of the pot, not basing on the probabilistic advantage recognized during the show–down phase, but in function of the skills involved by the single athlete in a given phase of the spot. All the logical-mathematical processes that allowed the measurement of such skills are presented, defining them as indexes for the intrinsic characteristic of information vagueness [Anolli, 2012], also inserting an applicative phase accompanied by the description of all the processes in every game condition.
The following chapters, III and IV, contain a case of study, which takes competitive advantage from the application of the new knowledge in the organisational sphere, describing a Digital Transformation process, with the adoption of the Social Enterprise Model to a structure dedicated to the production of live events and supported by the introduction of a Data Driven structure and the integration of digital systems conducting the productive activities. The complete description of every transformation process was presented (has been presented) -both from an organisational point of view with the indication of the new function roles, and from a strategical one based on Inbound and Content marketing methodologies- guided by the vision for the Champions Crew event of not being considered as a new competitor in the sector, but as a new contributor which, on a par with the other stakeholders, attempts to promote and spread the knowledge of the discipline from a cultural point of view and to contribute to power the entire economic industry. The presentation of the editorial plan and the description of the digital strategies adopted to launch and promote the event and the entire set of all the activities will close the paper.
The proposed evolutionary perspective, allows elaborating a professional version of the live discipline, developing the competitive dimension. The idea therefore is to realise a live tournament model of professional level, regulated and protected under the aegis of CONI; able to penalise decisions devoid of skill and enhancing those of skill, by proposing the introduction of indicators capable, in some way, of measuring the skills involved in the various phases of the spot – regardless of the actual concrete individual skills of the single athletes – universalistic-deterministic.
The integrity will be guaranteed by the possibility to bet all-in in every game phase, as for the original formula; whilst the overcoming of the encyclopaedic definition will be guaranteed by the introduction of the indicators, which, according to the game phase, will operate dynamically in relation to the skills involved in the respective game phases.
It can be asserted therefore that the skill index application of the new poker Texas Hold’em tournament model, proved to be an excellent influence modulation device of the two components padia and ludus – in favour of the latter – intrinsic to each game-sport activity, allowing to associate such discipline – in the live tournaments modality – on a par with the other olympic disciplines. Such Skills Index will in addition be capable of determining, through the elimination mechanism, the subject with the best performance of the entire agonistic competition.
The model shall be applied in all poker clubs, duly regulated, as integral part of a national championship.
Open the file to know the details of the reserch
CHAPTER III – Social Enterprise Model 79
III.1 – The poker live field 79
III.2 – The practice community and the social enterprise 83
CHAPTER IV – The Champions Crew case 86
IV.1 – Methodology 89
IV.2 – The organisational planning 90
IV.3 – Profit sharing plan 96
IV.4 – Communication plan 100
IV.4.1 – Internal policy 102
IV.4.2 – The crisis management 104
IV.4.4 – Editorial plan 105
- Anolli Luigi, Fondamenti di Psicologia della Comunicazione, Il Mulino, Bologna, 2012.
- Apel K.-O., Etica della comunicazione, Jaka Book S.p.A., Milano, 1992.
- Apostolico D., I Tornei di Poker e L’Arte della Guerra, DGS3 s.r.l., 2010.
- Bakker T., Analytical No-Limit Hold’em, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2011.
- Bateson G., Mente e Natura, ADELPHI Edizioni S.p.A., Milano, 1984.
- Bennato D., Sociologia dei media digitali, Gius. Laterza & Figli, Bari-Roma, 2011.
- Besana S., Collaborative company, EGEA S.p.A., Milano, 2018.
- Birkenbihl V. F., Segnali del Corpo, Franco Angeli s.r.l., Milano,1990.
- Boccia A. et al., Fenomenologia dei social network, Angelo Guerii e Associati s.r.l., Milano, 2017.
- Borzaga, C. (2009). L’impresa sociale. Bruni L., Zamagni S.(a cura di), 516-526.
- Boscaro A., Porta R., Effetto Digitale. Le nuove professioni, gli strumenti e il personal branding, Franco Angeli s.r.l., Milano, 2015.
- Bourdieu P., La rivoluzione simbolica, Marsilio Editori S.pA., Venezia, 2003.
- Brunson D., Super Sistem, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2011. Vol.I-II.
- Bruscaglioni M. e Gheno S., Il gusto di potere. Empowerment di persone ed azienda, Franco Angeli s.r.l., Milano, III Edizione.
- Caro M., Poker tells. Psicologia e body language nel poker, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2007.
- Cialdini R. B., Le armi della persuasione, Giunti O.S. Psychometrics s.r.l., Firenze, 2017.
- Cioffi A., Digital Strategy. Strategie per un efficace posizionamento sui canali digitali, Ulrico Hoepli Editore S.p.A, Milano, 2018.
- Corbetta P., Metodologia e tecniche della ricerca sociale, il Mulino, Bologna, 2014, II Edizione.
- Cosenza V., Social Media Roi, APOGEO, Milano, 2014.
- Cosenza G., Introduzione alla semiotica dei nuovi media, Gius. Laterza & Figli S.p.A., Bari-Roma, 2014.
- Csikszentmihalyi M., Flow: the psychology of optimal experience, Harper Perennial Modern Classic, New York, 1990.
- Corbetta, P. (1999). Metodologia e tecniche della ricerca sociale
- Dalla N., Alson P., One of a king, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2011.
- Diodato R. e Somaini A., Estetica dei media e della comunicazione, il Mulino, Bologna, 2011.
- Edmondson, A. C., McManus, S. E. (2007). Methodological fit in management field research. Academy of management review, 32(4), 1246-1264.
- Fabris A., Guida alle etiche della comunicazione, Edizioni ETS, Pisa, 2011.
- Fabris A., Etica della comunicazione, Carocci Editore S.p.A., 2006.
- Ferrari Zumbini F., Il nuovo poker, Arnoldo Mondadori Editore S.p.A., Milano, 2013.
- Flynn M., Metha S., Miller E., Professional No limit Hold’em Vol.1. Small stakes, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2008.
- Flynn M., Metha S., Miller E., No limit Hold’em. Small stakes, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2010.
- Goleman D., Intelligenza emotiva, Rizzoli Libri, Milano, 1996.
- Goffman E., La vita quotidiana come rappresentazione, il Mulino, Bologna, 1969.
- Gordon P., Little green book, DGS3 s.r.l., Roma, 2008.
- Gordon P., Little blue book, DGS3 s.r.l., Roma, 2009.
- Gordon P., Little gold book, DGS3 s.r.l., Roma, 2012.
- Habermas J., Etica del discorso, Gius. Laterza & Figli S.p.A., Bari-Roma, 1989.
- Harrigton D. e Robertie B., Cash Games, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2005, Vol. I-II.
- Harrigton D. e Robertie B., Harrington, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2005, Vol. I-II-III.
- Hilger M., Texas Hold’em Odds e Probabilità: Limit, No-limit e strategie da tornei, DGS3 s.r.l., 2008.
- Hjelmslev L., Il linguaggio, Giulio Einaudi Editore, Torino, 1963,
- Iabichino P., Invertising. Ovvero, se la pubblicità cambia il suo verso di marcia, Guerini Next s.r.l., Milano, 2016.
- Jenkins H., Ford S. e Green J., Spreadable media, Maggioli Editore, Santarcangelo di Romagna (Rn), 2013.
- Jonas H., Il principio di responsabilità, Giulio Einaudi Editore S.p.A., Torino, 1990.
- Jones G., Organizzazione. Teoria, progettazione, cambiamento, EGEA S.p.A., Milano, 2012.
- Kandel E. R. et al., Principi di neuroscienze, Casa Editrice Ambrosiana, Milano, 2015.
- Kotler P., Marketing 4.0, Ulrico Hoepli Editore S.p.A., Milano, 2017.
- Losito G., La ricerca sociale sui media, Carocci Editore S.p.A., Roma, 2009.
- Miller E., Sklansky D., Malmuth M., Small stakes hold’em, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2008.
- Negranu D., Power Hold’em Strategy, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2009.
- Paccagnella Luciano, Sociologia della comunicazione, Il Mulino, Bologna, 2010.
- Pedroni M., Coolhunting. Genesi di una pratica professionale eretica, Franco Angeli s.r.l., Milano, 2010.
- Poggi I., Le parole del corpo, Carocci Editore S.p.A., Roma, 2006.
- Prudesti A., Enterprise 2.0, Franco Angeli s.r.l., Milano, 2010.
- Ronchi M. e Ciancia M., Digital Trasformation, Franco angeli s.r.l., Milano, 2019.
- Rose F., Immersi nelle storie. Il mestiere di raccontare nell’era di internet, Frank Rose, Hollywood CA, 2010.
- Russo V., Psicologia della comunicazione e neuromarketing, Pearson Italia, Milano-Torino, 2017.
- Savron, G., Pitti, P., De Luca, R., & Guerreschi, C. (2001). Psicopatologia e gioco d’azzardo: uno studio preliminare su un campione di Giocatori d’Azzardo Patologici. Rivista di psichiatria, 36(1), 14-21.
- Schmidt D., Poker Business. Come trasformare un hobby in un impero, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2010.
- Schoonmaker A., Poker psychology, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (TN), 2010.
- Scotti E. e Sica R., Community Management, APOGEO s.r.l., Milano, 2010.
- Sklansky D., Hold’em poker advanced, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2007.
- Sklansky David, Teoria del poker, Boogaloo Publishing, 2008, Trad. It. a cura di Marco Trevix.
- Sklansky D., Tournament poker advanced, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2009.
- Snyder A., Poker Formula, Boogaloo Publishing, Rovereto (Tn), 2011. Voll. I,II.
- Stake, R. (1994), Case Studies, in Handbook of Qualitative Research, (a cura di) N. K. Denzin & Y. S. Lincoln, Sage, Thousand Oaks, Londra e New Delhi.
- Stake, R. (2005), Qualitative Case Studies, in The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research, (a cura di) N. K. Denzin e Y. S. Lincoln, Sage, Thousand Oaks, Londra e New Delhi.
- Stati, S. (2011). 241. Lexikologie und Semantik/Lessicologia e semantica. In Italienisch, Korsisch, Sardisch (pp. 83-93). Max Niemeyer Verlag.
- Tailor I. & Hilger M., Poker Mindset. Elementi fondamentali per avere successo nel poker, DGS3 s.r.l., Roma, 2008.
- Tani, F., & Ilari, A. (2016). La spirale del gioco: Il gioco d’azzardo da attività ludica a patologia (Vol. 530). Firenze University Press
- Tendler J., Il Mental game del poker, Jared Tendler, LLC, 2015.
- Triglia C., Sociologia economica. Profilo storico, Il Mulino, Bologna, 2002. Voll. I,II.
- Volli U., Manuale di semiotica, Gius. Laterza & Figli, Bari, 2003.
- Von Bertalanffy, L. (1950). An outline of general system theory. British Journal for the Philosophy of science.
- Wenger E., Comunità di pratica, Raffaello Cortina Editore, Milano, 2006.
- Zaccaria R. et al., Diritto dell’informazione e della comunicazione, Wolters Kluwer Italia, Milano, 2018.